Kincardine grapples with medical clinic addition
 By Liz Dadson

 

The proposed addition is to be built to the left and in front of the Kincardine Community Medical Clinic

Still reeling from the proposed $5-million addition to the Kincardine Community Medical Clinic, council has decided to sit down and discuss the project with the architects who came up with the idea.

During committee-of-the-whole Oct. 8, councillors again admitted being surprised at the huge expansion and high price tag presented by Parkin Architects of Toronto.

Councillor Marsha Leggett said she and councillor Gordon Campbell were part of the committee that chose the architect but she was away when the "wish list" was brought forward by Parkin.  "I would like council and the public to know that we met with Parkin and they received the amount, $2 million, which we planned to spend on one building that was 10,000 square feet in size," she said. "Now, we have multiple buildings at a cost of $5 million. I think we should go back to Parkin and tell them what we asked for and tell them to go back and see what they can come up with."

"We sure got an eye-opener," agreed councillor Randy Roppel, adding a committee should be struck to deal with the medical clinic addition and elected officials should be on that committee.

"We need a watchdog on this," said Campbell. "If the information doesn't come to council, how are we to make a decision?"

Mayor Larry Kraemer said Parkin was given a task to collect information about what the medical community wants pertaining to design and usage of the addition to the medical clinic. "We asked for 7,000 to 10,000 square feet on one floor, but it grew to 14,000 square feet," he said.
Councillor Ron Hewitt agreed with Roppel's idea of a committee to bring forward options for council to review.

However, deputy mayor Laura Haight said if a committee is to be struck, council must set up the parameters for it. She also was taken aback at the size of the project as presented by Parkin.

"We're not medical professionals," said Kraemer. "We're trying to enhance the attractiveness of our community by providing a good building for our medical community in order to serve our residents."

He said the idea of a Family Health Team set up in the lower level of the medical clinic is a bit premature, given the clinic is only at 60-per-cent capacity. "Where's the hurry of setting up a Family Health Team?" he asked.

(next column)

13/01/2009 04:24 PM

(continued)

Back entrance to the Kincardine Community Medical Clinic

Roppel said there is usable space in the basement of the clinic but the doctors are not interested in using it so it's dead space. "We have an opportunity to build for the future," he said. "There is a cost but there's a bigger cost if we have no doctors in town. Then we won't need a medical clinic or a hospital. If we get to that point, we'll be the fools."

Kraemer said the deficiencies in the lower level of the current facility have been corrected and the space can be used. Mould was found in the basement but it has since been removed and the lower level fixed up.

"I think the architect should go back to what we originally wanted," said councillor Guy Anderson. "We need a committee to bring back pertinent information."

Councillor Mike Leggett disagreed, saying a committee is a waste of time. "Let the medical community sort out what is needed and then it goes to corporate services (committee) for a decision."

"Council's input is basically here's how much money, where the addition is going and the size," said councillor Kenneth Craig.

"This would be a good project to put in for the new federal/provincial funding program (Ontario Building Canada Fund)," said Roppel.

"We have not had a good discussion with the architects," said Kraemer. "We should do that and clearly declare our expectations for the cost and size of this project. Then they can go to the medical community and figure out how to do this. We have to find some middle ground between us and the medical community."

Council agreed to have a discussion with the architects about the project.

The proposal by Parkin would see a 14,000 square foot addition on two levels with offices for 12 doctors, 30 examination rooms, a 2,000 square foot waiting room, patient washrooms and a nursing station. It would expand the clinical support and administration areas, provide a lunchroom, staff room and lockers. It would also include retail space of up to 4,200 square feet for McKechnie Pharmacy, which was forced to leave the lower floor of the existing clinic.