Heritage Committee NOT in favour of proposal to tear down Old Town Hall

Heritage

(continued)

SENSITIVITY TO THE PAST IS PART OF ECONOMIC GROWTH 

      Heritage Kincardine acts as stewards of heritage properties, conservation districts, marine heritage sites and archaeological resources.  The committee works very hard to prevent the demolition of these things.  They represent our community’s history, a history that we can actually see, touch and experience first hand.  When heritage buildings function as public spaces, they serve the community as a whole.  Such is the case with the Old Town Hall in Kincardine, a designated Heritage Property for over 25 years.  It is a representation of our collective civic memory.  Since 1872 it has been the centre of town life in Kincardine; politically, socio-culturally and economically.  Regardless of our conflicting opinions about the “look” of a building or even the style, the preservation of heritage buildings and other built structures and environments is extremely important for future generations; for their judgement, and wonderment, and feelings of their past.  And it teaches them about their history in ways that books and computers cannot.  The presence of the building allows all of us to ask questions important to our history: If it is a modest Town Hall, then why?  What makes our Town Hall different?  What makes it unique and interesting?   What is it about the building’s location that is important?  How can we properly preserve and display it?   

All of these things play an important economic role in our community.  Old buildings need to be economically viable and sustainable as well.  The misconception exists that new buildings are always more economical and more efficient than old ones.  New buildings need to be maintained just like old ones.  They can leak and lose heat too.  And they are also susceptible to mould.  The operating costs of new buildings can often be crippling because developers insist on pursuing inefficient, showy, and expensive designs that are sold to communities as “archi-tourism” draws.  Often over budget, with lengthy drawn-out construction schedules, the enormous cost and time delays incurred by new construction should not be underestimated. 

(next column)

09/07/2009 11:09 PM


Larger new construction projects also tend to import their architects, planners, consultants and even their labour rather than source locally.  Local contractors, builders, restoration architects and trades-people that are familiar with old buildings, source local materials and have a network of local trades people on hand to do the work.  Heritage-sensitive building projects that are adaptive and restorative add interest, complexity and depth to old buildings, which then enhance main streets and other built areas of a community.  This makes the adaptive re-use of buildings economically sensible and sustainable. 

In terms of progress, heritage, tourism and development are the same.  Heritage is not a barrier to economic growth but a source of wealth itself.  Kincardine is prudently developing a wonderful cultural heritage tourism sector.  Presently, this is the largest growing tourism sector in the world.  The success of our annual Doors Open event is proof of this at a local level. 

When we tear down a heritage building or even a building of heritage value, the affiliate culture is also gone forever.  “Heritage scenery” or proposed new-build fakes are devoid of culture and history, and appeal only to ever-changing notions of subjective opinion and trends.  Progress, development, economics and environmental sustainability all run parallel with the very notion of heritage.  The task for creative and intelligent developers is to promote ideas respectful of the past, and not to rehash polarised arguments of old is “bad” and new is “good”.  Demolition is not like purging a cluttered basement.  It is the irreversible destruction of our history.

To move Kincardine forward we should look to progressive and innovative precedents involving heritage buildings, and should strive to be always considerate of the community history that fuels and sustains progress itself.  A Performing Arts Centre in Kincardine’s existing Old Town Hall could be a model of this progress.  Therefore, Heritage Kincardine, as a standing committee of council, is NOT in favour of the proposal to demolish and replace the Old Town Hall. 

Heritage Kincardine Committee

for world news, books, sports, movies ...